About this Show

News Nation

News/Business. Tamron Hall. Tamron Hall provides context and informed perspectives on the stories making headlines. New.

NETWORK

DURATION
01:00:00

RATING

SCANNED IN
San Francisco, CA, USA

SOURCE
Comcast Cable

TUNER
Virtual Ch. 787 (MSNBC HD)

VIDEO CODEC
mpeg2video

AUDIO CODEC
ac3

PIXEL WIDTH
1920

PIXEL HEIGHT
1080

TOPIC FREQUENCY

Us 10, Obama 7, Boehner 5, Marco Rubio 4, Nancy Pelosi 4, Mitch Mcconnell 4, Washington 3, Lunesta 3, Paul Ryan 3, Janet Napolitano 3, John Boehner 3, Warfarin 3, Pentagon 3, Christopher Dorner 2, Gabby Giffords 2, Nbc 2, Dennis 2, Kelly O'donnell 2, Dorner 2, Bob 2,
Borrow a DVD
of this show
  MSNBC    News Nation    News/Business. Tamron Hall. Tamron Hall provides context and  
   informed perspectives on the stories making headlines. New.  

    February 13, 2013
    11:00 - 12:00pm PST  

11:00am
all stations come over to mithis is for real this time. step seven point two one two. verify and lock. command is locked. five seconds. three, two, one. standing by for capture. the most innovative software on the planet... dragon is captured. is connecting today's leading companies to places beyond it. siemens. answers. i'm tamron hall. the "news nation" is following developing news. the follow-up president obama picking up where he left off in the state of the union. just wrapping up a rally in north carolina. >> the perk was ordinary folk
11:01am
fist they worked hard, they could do well. our middle class when it's growing and thriving and there laters of opportunity for people to do better each year and make sure their kids are doing even better than them, that's the american dream. >> the president reiterating many proposals he pushed and including expanding preschool and equal pay for women and raising the current $7.25 minimum wage. >> tonight let's declare in the wealthiest nation on earth, no one who works full time should have to live in poverty and raise the federal minimum wage to $9 an hour. >> big response to that line from democrats and "the chicago tribune" writes, obama urges measures to boost little class. the goal reignites true engine of america. and detroit news and we know how
11:02am
special that city and state are to the country, obama urges sweeping effort to boost job creation. the moment they say is unusual for a state of the union. was the emotional call for congress to act on gun legislation calling the names, some of the victims of gun violence and families were there to hear it. >> gabby giffords deserves a vote, the families of newtown deserve a vote. the families of aurora deserve a vote. the families of oak creek and tucson and blacksburg and the countless other communities ripped open by gun violence deserve a simple vote. >> as for the republican response today on some of the issues laid out by the president, both speaker boehner and senate leader mitch mcconnell call the president's speech a missed opportunity.
11:03am
>> an opportunity to bring together the country and instead became a retread of lip service and liberalism. for democratic president entering his second term, it was simply unequal to the moment. following four years of this president's unwillingness to challenge liberal dogma. we got more of the same. >> i have been dealing with a minimum wage issue for the last 28 years that i have been elected office. when you raise the price of employment, guess what happens. you get less of it. in a time when the american people are asking where are the jobs, why would we want to make it harder for small employers to hire people. >> let's bring in the "news nation" panel and syndicated talk show host and contributor michael smerconish, cnbc contributor and columnist for
11:04am
reuters and the atlantic. lots of jobs for you. let me start off with you. you have a president talking about raising the minimum wage and the follow-up from republicans today is that that would hurt the jobs creators. an argument we hear often. is that an effective counter the day after for republicans? >> it might have been in the past, but i think the income disparity has taken such hold of the debate in the last year or 18 months, i think there is more momentum on the period's side for this issue than at any point previously. i discussed it on the radio and expected i would hear more opposition than i did. the people are ready for that kind of change. >> a couple of questions they said yesterday the president would need to answer. how can the united states create more jobs at home? did he adequately answer that? >> no, but this is in the realm
11:05am
of commentary. one thing we encounter is that there is a limit to what they can do to create jobs and the expectation that obama would wave a magic wand is a bit of a fiction that we participate in. it would be good if we stop participating in. >> what about incentives for companies who choose not to hire them? >> that was not a focus on this. this is more about things we are going to do. tax breaks and incentives is they feel particularly in a state of the union moment as fuzzy. they are a lot more effective. >> i want to play what paul ryan said in reaction to the president's address. let me play it. >> he's taking to the road for the next few days in campaign mode. he seems to always stay in a campaign mode where he treats people, the other party as the enemy and not as partners. if he wanted to get things done he would work for us instead of
11:06am
campaigning. >> he would work with us instead of campaigning around the country. is that fact, fiction or an opinion? >> it's just an opinion. every president does this after the state of the union. you saw it with gorge bush after he had the idea of privatizing social security. he went across the country to do that. this is a republican talking point. this idea that somehow obama doesn't want to work with the republicans and he is the who is obstructing poor progress in terms of the economy and other issues and he is always if campaign mode. it's not surprising that this is what they say again. i think you have a president that realizes he did well in 2012 and he has momentum and very much wants to go above the head of the folks in that audience. on the one hand, the audience was congress and also the american people. it's smart for him in keeping with what other presidents did. >> michael, with his stalemate
11:07am
or fever as it is described, why wouldn't the president go over the heads of congress? we are seeing some compromise, perhaps in the horizon when it comes to immigration reform as a result of the notion that elections have consequences and we know the experience of the latino vote for the gop if they are to recover. why is that an ineffective strategy or going to be criticized by paul ryan as part of the losing team. why not go over the heads if that's the notion, of congress to the people who end up voting and getting perhaps the house change so that nancy pelosi becomes the speaker again as the president said is his desire when he addressed the members of the house in washington, virginia. >> i agree with the way she laid it out and said more simply, he is good at it on the road. if you are the opposition party, that's the last place you want him. when he is making appearances like today, the net of that is
11:08am
pressure that gets put on members of congress. we listen to the president and he makes sense to us. that's why we want to keep him in washington. >> we want to play what the president had to say. you cannot cut prosperity and you see the cuts come down march 1st. let me play it. >> we can't ask senior citizens and working families to shoulder the entire burden of deficit reduction while asking nothing more from the wealthiest and the most powerful. we won't grow the middle class by shifting the cost of health care or college to families that are struggling. or by forcing communities to lay off more teachers and more cops and more firefighters. most americans, democrats, republicans, and independents, understand that we can't just cut our way to prosperity. >> mitch mcconnell said the sequester will happen and others
11:09am
said the same thing. was there anything in the president's speech that moved the needle towards a compromise? >> the only thing that moves it is it's clear that the republicans and if you listen to connell, these were not energetic next day rebuttals. ryan looked like he was falling asleep. of all the programs, we were talking about clinton getting out the laundry list and how the president is going to pay for it. almost nothing he presented carries this massive price tag. the $9 new minimum wage is on private industry. the only thing that shifted, if it happens and it hits domestic programs, it's going to be the republicans who are responsible. that's a credible argument. if we step back and all this talk about the huge liberal expansion, it was liberal rhetoric. we are not talking about a lot of spending, but continuing to contract sequester or not. >> let me bring in david price
11:10am
which by the way was the first stop for the president's post state of the union tour. thank you for your time. >> thank you. >> your colleague was just on with andrea mitchell and said the democrats need to produce a budget and everything falls into place, blaming the president and democrats for not producing a budget here. we are looking at sequester. mitch mcconnell said it will take place. some republicans believe that the democrats will be to blame for this. >> well, the notion that the president should sit down and work with paul ryan and his colleagues is just flying in the face of what these guys have said themselves in recent days. remember john boehner said he wasn't going to do any more big deals or even try. he knows these folks in the republican conference won't vote for anything. mitch mcconnell said the discussion is over and no more talk of revenues. just a summary statement.
11:11am
what have they got to offer? are they sitting down to work it out? no. they offer yet another crisis and sequential series of efforts to shut it down so as to get their way. all they have got to offer is that and that means the sequester will come and a lot of republicans are saying let it come. in effect, don't worry about slowing down the growth rate and the job impact. let it come. >> the belief is that republicans think if it comes, folks say here are the democrats and the president asking for tax revenue as a solution and perhaps that will bring on heat. i will have to bring up what speaker boehner said. just before the state of the union saying that the president getting personal and saying he has no guts to stand up to his own party. matt lauer asking about that on the "today" show. here's what he said. >> during the debt talks, he didn't have the courage to take on the members of his own party.
11:12am
i had troubles with my own party. no question about it. it was never about the courage to step up and do the right thing for the country. >> the president discussed the deal on the table back in december that included reforms to entitlements. he alluded to it last night in the state of the union, not in great detail. this notion that he is afraid to face the issues that might fire up republicans and progressives. >> when you look at the debt and deficit deals of the past in the 1990s, four years of balanced budgets, let us pay off 400 million. those look very much like obama's december offer to john boehner which john boehner just couldn't get the votes for. remember boehner had a fall back plan that was less ambitious. he couldn't get the votes for that. now he said this discussion is over. what do we conclude? obama made a good offer. he reiterated last night and
11:13am
said we already cut a trillion and a half out of appropriated spending and some revenue out of the fiska will cliff deal and have a ways yet to go. let's have a balanced course as we work this out. the republicans have said we are not talking and the reality is the republican caucus is so extreme that they couldn't get the votes for a deal if they had one. >> thank you so much very much. the president is heading out of your home state on his first stop after the state of the union. let me get back to the panel here. i want to play what marco rubio had to say in the gop response prior to the water drink. prior or after. i don't know if anything matters. you take that sip of water and what he said about his personal story. >> this ideal is personal. my parents emigrated for the opportunity to improve their life. they made it to the middle class. my dad as a bartender and my
11:14am
mother as a cashier and maid. i didn't inherit money from them. i live in the same middle class neighborhood i grew up in. i owed over $100,000. a debt i paid off just a few months ago. >> his story is not that mitt romney could tell or touch. chris matthews said rubio said government is not the answer, but talked about medicare for his mother and a student loan he received that perhaps allow him to be the senator that he is today. what do you make of the conflict there? >> i think that senator rubioey performance is fine. i am not hung up on the water incident. >> the issue of the role of government. >> substantively the short coming to answer the question is he didn't do anything in that speech to expand the tent. the issue that you raise about the role of government is an
11:15am
example of where there koochb compromise, but it hasn't been forth comprehending. he had a good presentation, but the same set of remarks with a different and perhaps more appealing face delivering them. >> as you are talking about the substance, we are talking about the water. it was over 90,000 tweets. his issue about the role of government and we talked about this a lot. there is not just a mote, but there is maybe the grand canyon between the two parties over the role of government. these are ideological differences that will not be solved. >> it reminds you of the famous obama care saying government, hands off my medicare from the tea party. there is a greater realm of agreement amongst the american people about certain basic needs that government meets. whether it's roads and faa and
11:16am
certain provision of health care and benefits to those who can't afford them. there is just this issue in washington and the reality is, clearly this state of the union shows two things. government spending is contracted whether you are democrat or republican. we are talking about the margins. the republican line of constant crisis and manufacturing crisis is simply not going to work politically. >> thank you. it's a great pleasure and we have breaking news. military officials say john allen is likely to withdraw his name and nomination to be the next commander in europe. he has been the top u.s. and nato commander in afghanistan. pentagon correspondent joins us with the latest. why is he withdrawing if this is accurate? >> we are told that he is strongly considering and more likely than not to withdraw his name. he hasn't made the final decision until he talks to
11:17am
president obama. general allen got caught up in the sex and e-mail scandal involving then cia director david petraeus. in thousands of e-mails, several hundred were between general allen and a socialite down there in tampa. according to officials who have seen these e-mails, the vast majority were innocent about military events around tampa. a couple that some people in the obama administration and here in the pentagon thought were a little bit suspect. they had the inspector general here at the pentagon launching an investigation. after this exhausted investigation which was finally concluded and it was determined that general allen was involved in no misconduct, no inappropriate language or communications with this socialite, he was cleared of that.
11:18am
in the meantime, his nomination to be the supreme allied commander of europe had been put on hold. the white house has not yet although they support allen has not yet sent that nomination back to the hill and we are told that general allen may not and is strongly considering withdrawing from the nomination because he doesn't want to resurrect that controversy and put he and his family through it. one other thing. there may be family health issues involved here. again, he has not met with president obama and we are told that if president obama tries to talk him into it to go ahead and accept the nomination that it is likely that general allen would decline. >> thank you very much. we are following another breaking news story. the search for the former l.a. cop accused of murder. christopher dorner. police are working to confirm whether dorner died in the shootout and fire at a cabin in
11:19am
los angeles. we will get the latest live from the scene. plus, i will talk with the daily beast who said president obama needed to hammer the gop and expose the dishonesty in the state of the union. what does he think of marco rubio and what he did to make his party's case? join the conversation on twitter and find me. the team at "news nation." so you say men are superior drivers? yeah. then how'd i get this... [ voice of dennis ] ...safe driving bonus check? every six months without an accident, allstate sends a check. ok. [ voice of dennis ] silence. are you in good hands? he can talk to china, mongolia and all the koreas and he eats velveeta shells and cheese. so who are you calling amateur? liquid gold. eat like that guy you know.
11:20am
11:21am
11:22am
we have an update out of los angeles where police say the body believed to have belonged to fugitive christopher dorner has note yet been positively identified. dorner's case is still open and they will continue to be until
11:23am
they have a positive id. sources tell us the charge remains found in the cabin belongs to doerper and dorner's driver's license was found near the. the family that he promised to target are still living in fear and we have amazing video of the gun fight that unfolded yesterday as a cbs reporter found himself feet away from the line of fire. >> one deputy was kill and another seriously identified. neither has been identified. we have the very latest. john, what is the timeline we are looking at here. dorner is a former police officer. would they have his dental records, for example, in archive to expedite this? >> they would have his dental records from family members and dna samples from his mother or sister. the san bernardino county coroner is examining the
11:24am
remains. it's not clear how long it will take that make that id. if this was the final chapter last night, it was right out of a movie. he was holed up in one cabin, discovered when two women came to clean it and fled in of their vehicles and wracked that vehicle and was spotted by california fish and wildlife wardens and wrecked the first vehicle and had to steal another one at gunpoint. >> he came up to me with his gunpointed at me. he said i don't want to hurt you. get out and start walking up the road and take your dog which is what i did. >> he fled in that vehicle and passed another california fish and wildlife warden. as he passed, he rolled down his window and fired shots at the warden. the warden stopped and pulled out his rifle and fired at dorner as he fled down the road.
11:25am
dorner wrecked that vehicle. he was spotted by san bernardino county sheriff's deputies running into the woods. they followed his tracks into the woods and came to this other cabin. there was a shootout where one deputy was shot and one killed. they were trying to get him out and heard a single gunshot from inside and then a fire broke out. tamron? >> thank you very much for the latest from there. last week president obama said he expects that nancy pelosi would soon be speaker once again. was the president trying to tee up pelosi for 2014 in his state of the union? >> his political calculation clearly last night is i will never get the republicans to work with me, let's start running nancy pelosi as speaker tonight. >> i will get the first read on this. first, the senate is expected to take a vinyl vote tomorrow on former republican senator chuck
11:26am
hagel's nomination to be the next secretary of defense. confirmation is expected after the armed services committee approved late yesterday by a vote of 14-11. no republicans voted for hagel. . she was a picky eater. well now i'm her dietitian and last year, she wasn't eating so well. so i recommended boost complete nutritional drink to help her get the nutrition she was missing. and now she drinks it every day. well, it tastes great! [ male announcer ] boost has 26 essential vitamins and minerals, including calcium and vitamin d to support strong bones, and 10 grams of protein to help maintain muscle. and our great taste is guaranteed or your money back. learn more at boost.com [ dietitian ] now, nothing keeps mom from doing what she loves... being my mom. a regular guy with an irregular heartbeat. the usual, bob? not today. [ male announcer ] bob has afib: atrial fibrillation not caused by a heart valve problem, a condition that puts him at greater risk for a stroke. [ gps ] turn left. i don't think so.
11:27am
[ male announcer ] for years, bob took warfarin, and made a monthly trip to the clinic to get his blood tested. but not anymore. bob's doctor recommended a different option: once-a-day xarelto®. xarelto® is the first and only once-a-day prescription blood thinner for patients with afib not caused by a heart valve problem, that doesn't require routine blood monitoring. like warfarin, xarelto® is proven effective to reduce the risk of an afib-related stroke. there is limited data on how these drugs compare when warfarin is well managed. no routine blood monitoring means bob can spend his extra time however he likes. new zealand! xarelto® is just one pill a day, taken with the evening meal. and with no dietary restrictions, bob can eat the healthy foods he likes. do not stop taking xarelto® rivaroxaban without talking to the doctor who prescribes it for you. stopping may increase your risk of having a stroke. get medical help right away if you develop any signs or symptoms of bleeding, like unusual bruising or tingling. you may have a higher risk of bleeding
11:28am
if you take xarelto® with aspirin products, nsaids or blood thinners. talk to your doctor before taking xarelto® if you currently have abnormal bleeding. xarelto® can cause bleeding, which can be serious, and rarely may lead to death. you are likely to bruise more easily on xarelto®, and it may take longer for bleeding to stop. tell your doctors you are taking xarelto® before any planned medical or dental procedures. before starting xarelto®, tell your doctor about any conditions, such as kidney, liver or bleeding problems. ready to change your routine? ask your doctor about once-a-day xarelto®. for more information including cost support options, call 1-888-xarelto or visit goxarelto.com.
11:29am
>> his political calculation clearly last night was i am never going to get the republicans to work with me. let's start running nancy pelosi as speaker tonight. >> nbc news mark murray. what clues were in the speech that i guess would pay off with joe's thinking there. >> i would say that 2014 is a long way away. eight years ago won reelection and a lot of people were talking
11:30am
about how republicans were a majority and we found out in the races. things can change and it takes a while for them to change. one thing that was a combative speech and particularly when it came to climate change, he is going to take executive action on his own. i would make one counter. one matter where there seems to be a place it get things done. president obama was congenial and he devoted or two paragraphs to that. he wants congress to do his job and keeps pushing. >> we know there other issues and raising the minimum wage. speaker boehner saying it would hurt those who create jobs. that would be a non-starter. i don't know how they find
11:31am
compromise. issues related to voters and the president highlighting 102-year-old woman whoa had to stand in line for hours. there is not a rush job that was brought up. prior to the election in november by democrats. you are right regarding immigration. looking at the big picture, that's the only way to stop the fever for the democrats to control the house. >> it depens on whether it's to get everything you want accomplished. president obama wants to get more accomplished, yes, having democrats taking back the house is their objective. i would say that will be difficult to do with redistricting. they want an election and only able to pick up eight house seats. you look at what president obama is doing and you are right. on the issues you laid out, he was building a trap that opposes them.
11:32am
>> mark murray, great following ow twitter during the speech as well. >> thank you. >> you're welcome. coming up -- protests interrupt homeland security secretary janet napolitano's testimony. a senate hearing that took place a few hours ago. the latest on what happened there. first, there is a lot going on today and here are things we thought you should know. nbc's kelly o'donnell reports during the most emotional part of the president's speech last night when he was talking about gun legislation, a woman took up the president's call for action and shouted out a name, possibly that of her family member a victim of gun violence. it's tough to hear, but listen closely as the applause dies down, someone faintly shouts after the president finished speaking. >> they deserve a simple vote.
11:33am
they deserve a simple vote. >> kelly o'donnell said the woman was quietly escorted out of the chamber. before taking the podium, he had a special greeting and a fist bump. the 53-year-old republican returned to work after having a stroke last year. those are the things we thought you should know.
11:34am
11:35am
11:36am
more reaction to the president's state of the union address. he did not hesitate to take a tough tone from climate change to the never ending budget
11:37am
battles. >> they cannot drift from manufactured crisis to the next. let's agree to keep the people's government open and pay bills on time and always uphold the full faith and credit of the united states of america. i urge this congress to getting to and pursue a bipartisan solution to climate change like the one john mccain and joe lieberman worked on. if congress won't act soon to protect future generations, i will. >> let's bring in the daily beast who urged the president to hammer the gob. good to see you. did the president take your advice? >> i think he did. specifically with reference to the budget cuts that loom and with regard to that issue, i
11:38am
think he was very tough on the republicans. he came out and framed the issue the way he wanted and i was glad to see he started the speech after the introductory remarks. the lead line is march 1st. i was glad to hear him say that the american people that the republicans are playing a game here. i'm not going to have it. >> they said the speech was a christmas wish list. michael? >> in some respects, sure. as your guests said, it does seem unlikely that the things will be law by january if you look at the total package off the top of your head, give me the two big ones.
11:39am
>> immigration is first on the list. i'm a naysayer and that gets through the house of representatives the day i see it. immigration is one. it still has a better chance than a lot of other things. i don't know. it's a tough list. boehner said the minimum wage is not going anywhere. i still think it's valued for him as the leader of the country to lay out a vision for what he thinks the society ought to look like. that still has value. >> quickly before we let you go, one of the things you took issue with today, republicans and what they stood up for during the state of the union and what they choose not to, no republicans standing for voting rights, the 102-year-old woman in the audience there. why do you take issue with this? we know this happens with the state of the union. >> i think they look really bad. they look self-is crediting.
11:40am
it's true that the democrats don't applaud for a lo of things that ran ald reagan and george bush said. the republicans don't applaud for what barack obama said. they sat like statues for the moving invocations of those shooting victims and that woman voted down in florida, i think they look bad not applauding for those things and history won't judge them well. >> thank you very much. we have a great article as well. you will review his performance. talk with you soon. coming up, our "news nation" gut check. do you think the president can accomplish what he laid out in the state of the union. half and half. you can weigh in on the gut check today.
11:41am
have given way to sleeping. tossing and turning where sleepless nights yield to restful sleep. and lunesta®(eszopiclone) can help you get there. like it has for so many people before. when taking lunesta, don't drive or operate machinery until you feel fully awake. walking, eating, driving, or engaging in other activities while asleep, without remembering it the next day, have been reported. lunesta should not be taken together with alcohol. abnormal behaviors may include aggressiveness, agitation, hallucinations, or confusion. in depressed patients, worsening of depression, including risk of suicide, may occur. alcohol may increase these risks. allergic reactions such as tongue or throat swelling occur rarely and may be fatal.
11:42am
side effects may include unpleasant taste, headache, dizziness, and morning drowsiness. ask your doctor if lunesta is right for you. then find out how to get lunesta for as low as fifteen dollars at lunesta.com. there's a land of restful sleep. we can help you go there on the wings of lunesta. to find you a great deal, even if it's not with us. [ ding ] oh, that's helpful! well, our company does that, too. actually, we invented that. it's like a sauna in here. helping you save, even if it's not with us -- now, that's progressive! call or click today. no mas pantalones!
11:43am
when you lost the thing you can't believe you lost.. when what you just bought, just broke. or when you have a little trouble a long way from home... as an american express cardmember you can expect some help. but what you might not expect, is you can get all this with a prepaid card. spends like cash. feels like membership. >>. >> the senate committee is taking a step towards
11:44am
immigration reform where the emotion surrounding this issue quickly became clear. protesters demanding an end to deportations and janet napolitano's protesters were there twice more by other protesters. the secretary insisted that the border has never been more secure, something that they have questioned. >> according to the general accountability office, the department apprehends about 61% of people who crossed the border illegally in 2011. my question is, do you consider that a record to be proud of and count that as success or how would you characterize it? >> i would characterize it as one of the many members that
11:45am
float around. other show that net migration is negative. more people are going south than coming north and that substantial progress has been made. are we done? no. >> this comes after president obama renewed the call for immigration reform. joining me live, senior political reporter for politico and "usa today" contributor. raul, it was not just the president who addressed the comprehensive reform. rand paul and his tea party as well as senator marco rubio here. a lot of people are saying it is so linked to border security that we won't deal with the problem of immigration. >> that are has been the case in the past. they link it to enforce am. it's a stalling technique that they set new goals and can never be met and never go forward with comprehensive reform.
11:46am
as much as i do support the dreamers and the rights of the immigrants, it seemed that the hearings, the timing was off in interrupting janet napolitano's questioning. she had a very important point to make as a former governor and current head of dhs. our borders have never been stronger. that was a terrific point. >> people are not coming into this country because there no jobs. it's part of the recession, right? >> the magnet has been jobs. it's a chicken and egg game. do we need to secure the borders first or jobs? most agree we need a solution. we go around and around in this type of game. >> michael was on a second ago with the daily beast. we were talking about the odds of what the president can be successful with with his agenda. immigration reform is the thing that people name instantly. he said you believe it when you see the vote from house republicans on this issue. what are the odds here?
11:47am
are we too optimistic because we are hearing so many voices? >> i'm not sure we are too optimistic. i think there is a good chance and hashing out things now. the big issue is the path to citizenship. a lot of them don't know what's in the proposal yet. conservative members who will leave this fight say once they see what the proposals are and that calls for enforcement and border security. when you have people like jeff and marco rubio leaving this effort in the senate, i think it's going to have teeth. >> you mentioned the conservative members of the senate. i want to play what lindsay graham had to say about potential problems ahead. >> if i had to bet where this thing could run into a roadblock, it wouldn't be on the
11:48am
pathway to citizenship as long as it's earn and not a special pathway. we are all signed up for that. e verify and some new system to control employment, we are all signed up for that. here's the friction point. temporary workers are needed in the future. a legal source of labor for american workers. the goal is not to displace an american worker. you can get a temporary worker when there is no american available at a competitive wage. >> the devil is in the detail. >> we're hear enough details from the president regarding work visas and the more complicated issues that may arise? >> no, but that's by design. the democrats are telling him to stay out of the details right now. if he starts putting down ultimatums or starts saying what he wants, republicans are going to run the other way. republicans will say it privately and democrats say it
11:49am
publicly, stay back. let both houses harsh this out and don't get into the minutia of it and that being said, i'm sure the democrats are talking to the white house behind the scenes. >> quickly. >> i agree. he cannot at this stage get too involved in the details. there so many republican devoted to ob strucking him that will not work in practical terms. on the response, immigration is supposed to be his signature issue and many in the community and latino community were disappointed there were only three sentences. >> thank you. a great pleasure. thank you. >> pope benedict cell brits his last public mass and that tops our look around the nation. he presides over an ash wednesday mass. the venue was moved to the basilica to make room for the larger crowds expected after he announced he is stepping down. frustrations are mounting for
11:50am
passengers on a carnival cruise that lost power in the gulf of mexico and slowly being towed back to the u.s. 3,000 people have been stranded for four days. a report of overflowing toilets and foul smells making people sick. the ship is expected to arrive in alabama tomorrow. can't wait to see that one. nbc's first lead team said the state of the union yon could be the tale of two speeches. part traditional and something you rarely see. emotions. we will go live.
11:51am
11:52am
11:53am
11:54am
>> last night's speech was a tale of two addresses. one emotional and one traditional. >> 51 years ago, john f. kennedy declared to this chamber that the constitution makes us not rivals for power, but partners for progress. gabby giffords deserves a vote. the families of newtown deserve a vote. the families of aurora deserve a vote. the families of oak creek and tucson and blacksburg and the countless other communities ripped open by gun violence deserve a simple vote. >> joining me now, presidential historian douglas. we played the beginning of the
11:55am
speech and you see the ending there. chuck todd and others said it is so rare in the state of the union to see that kind of emotion. what are your thoughts? >> chuck is right. we were waiting for it. everybody knew gun control is the vote and it came towards the end of the speech. it was barack obama on the mountain top, if you like. he took kind of a pastor-like way of raising the roof of the joint session. it was chilling where he named all of those places with people who died of violence while he has been president. one of the things about the speeches, something that scholars years from now, 20 years or 100 years from now as an indicator of what's going on in the country and the president meat it clear that it was a deep concern of his. >> what about the choice of words, they deserve a vote. not saying what to do, but these
11:56am
americans deserve a vote. >> i thought it was the right way to do it and brilliant. i don't know who wouldn't say let's at least have a vote on it. what are we doing if we can't vote on gun control measures and see how it plays out. i think he scored on that. there were a lot of historic moments and the media said part of it, he dealt with climate and then last night. i'm starting to think he is going to champion or educate the country about climate change and even connecting it to hurricane sandy last night. >> you heard the president refer to the warmest seasons we have seen on record. the incredible storms that we have seen as well. it has been greatly ignored. we talked a lot about immigration and we are just gate
11:57am
getting to climate and the president's address. it is intriguing in many ways. i don't know the reason why, but you heard the president say the science is there. i was intrigued by the reaction as you well know it is debated. president obama has all of the science coming from there and on and on. he is clear that will be interesting. some people thought it might be the jobs he can provide, but after the speech, i wonder if he is going for a progressive person on the left. >> you are right to bring that up. there was something regarding that. the state department reviews that. thank you and appreciate that. do you think the president can accomplish what he laid out in the state of the union. what does your gut tell you today. go to facebook.com to cast the vote. that does it for us.
11:58am
thanks for joining us. i will talk with the author of killer captors, the war on terror and the soul of the obama presidency. rachel smock lib. the cycle is up accident in. ...with a store full of ways to get it done. we can all throw on our work clothes... ...and throw out any doubt. because right now's the time to take those rooms from... ..."think i can do this?" to... ..."let me show you what i just did." more saving. more doing. that's the power of the home depot. outsmart your budget with this shaker vanity, a special buy at just $199.
11:59am
[ whispering ] that's crazy, the cookie's the best part. crème. cookie. crème. stop yelling. you stop yelling. [ whispering ] both of you stop yelling. [ whispering ] i'm trying to read. [ male announcer ] choose your side at oreo.com. that's a good thing, but it doesn't cover everything. only about 80% of your part b medical expenses. the rest is up to you. so consider an aarp medicare supplement insurance plan, insured by unitedhealthcare insurance company. like all standardized medicare supplement plans, they help save you up to thousands in out-of-pocket costs. call today to request a free decision guide. with these types of plans, you'll be able to visit any doctor or hospital that accepts medicare patients... plus, there are no networks,

Terms of Use (10 Mar 2001)